The Ocean Endeavor liner, former cruise ship Kristina Katarina. Wreck of the yacht "Team Vestas Wind" Wreck of sailing yachts

In August, shocking photos and videos of a drowning woman off the coast of Greece Mykonos superyachts have rocked the internet. The purity of the water at the crash site made it possible to examine what happened in detail. Fortunately, the crew of four managed to escape from the stranded and sinking 33-meter Aloha- they then helped local authorities prevent a fuel spill.

Yacht knockout of Mexican boxer Jorge Kawahi

Eyewitnesses managed to film how the hurricane ironed the property belonging to the Mexican politician, actor and former boxer Jorge Kawahi yacht Bellisima standing in the marina Acapulco. Unfortunately, the ship never managed to survive this storm - it sank.

Fire, water and Maltese Falcon

In September near Posilipo V Italy a fire started on the yacht of the owner of a football club " Napoli» Aurelio De Laurentiis, 31 meters Angra. Aurelio himself, along with his wife and 10 guests, was on board at that moment. All passengers managed to leave the yacht and reach the shore unharmed, but the yacht, most likely, cannot be restored. In one of the photographs taken by eyewitnesses of the fire, Angra is burning in front of the famous sailing ship.

Powder keg off the coast of Greece

Close to Piraeus 25 meter yacht Ocean 5 was rocked by several explosions. A fire started on the ship and then it sank. At the time of the incident there were 10 people on board, all of them managed to jump into the sea and escape.

Death of a Legend

The shipyard's classic 1953 yacht perished in a fire while awaiting repair work in Huntsville, Alabama. Among the owners of the 78-ft. Notorious- President of the U.S.A Gerald Ford and media mogul Randolph Hearst. This boat during filming Planet of the Apes used by actor Charlton Heston. Unfortunately, the fire almost completely destroyed the yacht standing on the pier: it was taken out in parts. There was no one on board at the time of the fire.

Undoubtedly, the most famous round-the-world sailing race in recent times is the VOLVO OCEAN RACE. It is held once every 3 years, and Volvo 65 class sailing yachts take part in it. The Volvo 65 is a single-hull, single-mast sailing yacht with a maximum hull length of 21.5 meters and a maximum draft of 4.5 meters. The swinging false keel deviates from the vertical axis by no more than 45°. The team consists of 10 people plus a special correspondent on board who has no right to participate in the management of the yacht. The task of this person is to prepare and send photo, video, and audio materials about the progress of the race and the work of the team. The winner of the regatta is the team that scores the maximum number of points at all stages of the regatta. Based on the results of the ocean stages, the team receives a number of points equal to the number of yachts that started, minus the number of yachts that finished before the given team.

The VOLVO OCEAN RACE race contains 9 stages, and the length of the route is almost 40,000 nautical miles. The 2014-2015 race started in October 2014 in Spain and should finish at the end of June 2015 in Gothenburg, Sweden, circling the globe.

Yachts of the Volvo 65 class are equipped with the most modern navigation equipment, as well as the latest satellite communications.

VOLVO OCEAN RACE 2014-2015 started on October 11, 2014 from the port of Alicante (Spain). 7 yachts under the control of the most experienced professional skippers crossed the starting line. The first stage of the race – Alicante – Cape Town (South Africa) ended in early November 2014. The second stage of the round-the-world trip – Cape Town – Abu Dhabi (UAE) started on November 19, 2014 and finished in the capital of the United Arab Emirates on the eve of Christmas and New Year 2015. However, out of seven yachts that started, only six reached the finish line. While crossing the Indian Ocean, the Danish yacht “Team Vestas Wind”, under the command of the most experienced skipper Chris Nicholson, was wrecked.

Fortunately, no casualties were avoided, but the yacht dropped out of further combat.

Tens of thousands of fans of this race around the world to this day remain in extreme bewilderment, how did a ship equipped with the most modern navigation aids, driven by a four-time VOLVO OCEAN RACE veteran, the most experienced Chris Nicholson, end up on the reefs?! How did the yacht sink? How could it happen that the ship's course was laid through the reefs indicated on all the maps?!

Here's what we know. By the evening of November 29, 2014, the yacht “Team Vestas Wind” arrived in the reef area of ​​the Cargados Carajos Shoal reefs, located approximately 200 miles northeast of the island. Mauritius (Mauritius). These reefs are also known as St. Brandon's Rocks. The reef stretches from north to south for more than 50 km, and is about 5 km wide. And that same night, unexpectedly for everyone, the yacht hit the reef. Fortunately, only the ship was damaged. All crew members survived and were evacuated the next day by rescuers who arrived.

At a press conference, Chris Nicholson explained: “Before the disaster, we noted that there were seamounts in the area, depths ranging from 3000 m to 40 m. There was little current in the area, and we decided that a depth of 40 m was more than safe for passage ."

What was this “issue of scale” that led to the crash? Let's figure it out.

We remember from school that scale is the ratio of the linear dimensions of the image of an object in the drawing to its actual dimensions. Those. if we see numbers on the map - 1: 100,000, this means that one centimeter on the map is equal to one hundred thousand centimeters on the ground. Or, in other words, 1 cm – 1 km.

In the pre-computer era, a classification of marine navigation charts by scale and purpose was adopted:

  • general (scale 1:5,000,000 - 1:1,000,000);
  • track (scale 1: 1,000,000 - 1: 100,000);
  • private (scale 1: 100,000 - 1:25,000);
  • sea ​​plans (scale 1:25,000 - 1:500);

General charts are intended for a general study of navigation conditions and general navigation calculations, preliminary navigation when sailing in the open sea at a great distance from the coast. Route charts - to ensure navigation between ports at a considerable distance from the coast and out of sight. Private charts - to ensure navigation in close proximity to the shore or in cramped conditions (in narrows, skerries, etc.) Marine plans - for guidance when entering ports, bays, roadsteads, anchorages, etc.

From the very first lessons on navigation at a nautical school, cadets are taught that navigation plots should be carried out on a map of the largest scale available for a given navigation area. But this was in the pre-computer era. With the advent of chart plotters and electronic cartographic navigation systems, navigators were able to independently change the scale of the electronic map image. And many, having become accustomed to the idea of ​​the infallible accuracy of electronics, having unreasonably endowed smart devices with intelligence, stopped thinking about the seemingly simplest features of computer cartography. This is what the Cargados-Carajos reef looks like on an electronic map at a scale of approximately 1:500,000:

It is not difficult to notice that the reef, as such, is not visible. Just some two blue spots and no more. Using something like this image, the navigator of “Team Vestas Wind” plotted the same fateful course that led the yacht to the rocks.

But in the figure below, the same reef is on the same electronic map, only on a scale of approximately 1:250,000.


DEFINITION

About the writ

Moscow Case No. A40-71869/14

02.12.2014

Arbitration court composed of: presiding judge Dzyuba D.I.,

When keeping the minutes by the secretary of the court session, E.S. Malyugina,

Having considered the case on the claim in open court

Individual entrepreneur Yuri Vasilyevich Tuzov (183025, Murmansk region, Murmansk, Spolokhi str., 7, apt. 82, date of birth July 8, 1961, place of birth - Murmansk, OGRNIP 309519027500064, TIN 519100537846, date registration 02.10.2009)

To the Open Joint Stock Company "MSK Insurance Group" (127006, Moscow, Dolgorukovskaya St., 40, OGRN 1021602843470, TIN 1655006421, registration date 04/19/1993)

3rd party: Limited Liability Company "PILIGRIM.RU" (183001, Murmansk region, Murmansk, Tralovaya St., 51, OGRN 1025100845582, INN 5190110248)

About collection of funds

On counterclaim

OJSC Insurance Group MSK

To Individual Entrepreneur Yuri Vasilievich Tuzov

On invalidation of the insurance contract,

With the participation of representatives:

From the plaintiff – Smirnova N.L. by power of attorney No. b/n dated July 4, 2014, passport,

For the defendant – V.A. Sokolov. by power of attorney No. 0028 dated January 1, 2014, passport,

Ilyenko G.Yu. by power of attorney No. 1597 dated November 17, 2014, passport,

From the 3rd person - no appearance, notified,

INSTALLED:

Individual entrepreneur Yuri Vasilievich Tuzov filed a claim with the Arbitration Court against the Open Joint-Stock Company "MSK Insurance Group" to recover insurance compensation in the amount of RUB 7,106,085. 00 kop.

OJSC "MSK Insurance Group" filed a counterclaim against Individual Entrepreneur Yu.V. Tuzov, LLC "PILIGRIM.RU" to invalidate the insurance contract (insurance policy No. STA/5101/0002506 dated March 28, 2012).

From the case materials it follows that on March 28, 2012, an insurance agreement was concluded between PILIGRIM.RU LLC and MSK Insurance Group OJSC (insurance policy No. STA/5101/0002506) of property interests related to the possession, use, and disposal of the insured vessel (motor-sailing vessel Yacht "KATARINA", registration number 183, the place of storage and laying of which is the city of Murmansk.

On 04/01/2012, lease agreement No. 1 was concluded between Individual Entrepreneur Yuri Vasilievich Tuzov and PILIGRIM.RU LLC.

The beneficiary under the Insurance Agreement is Individual Entrepreneur Yu.V. Tuzov. (clause 2 of the insurance contract, purchase and sale agreement dated January 24, 2008).

In accordance with clause 6.1 of the insurance contract, an insured event is death and damage, including hijacking and theft, including damage due to the complete loss of the insured vessel (actual or constructive).

According to the case materials, on February 20, 2013, the motor-sailing vessel Yacht “KATARINA”, registration number 183, was in disaster.

The crew of the motor-sailing vessel Yacht "KATARINA" (captain S.I. Kuritsyn, chief engineer A.S. Chernyavsky) decided to leave the ship, after which the crew was discovered and taken on board the M-0631 "Murmanryba" vessel.

The court questioned witness S.I. Kuritsyn at the hearing.

Witness Chernyavsky A.S. sent a telegram to the court, in which he undertook to appear for questioning as a witness at the Arbitration Court of the Murmansk Region.

In order to establish the circumstances relevant to the case, the court granted the petition of Individual Entrepreneur Yu.V. Tuzov. on the interrogation as witnesses of a crew member of the sailing-motor vessel Yacht “KATARINA”, senior engineer Chernyavsky A.S. and the captain of the vessel “Murmanryba” Sintsov S.V.

The consideration of the case was postponed to 02/03/2015.

Since these witnesses are located on the territory of another subject of the Russian Federation, the court finds it necessary in accordance with Art. Art. , Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation to instruct the Arbitration Court of the Murmansk Region to summon and interrogate A.S. Chernyavsky as witnesses. and Sintsov S.V., reflecting their testimony in the minutes of the court hearing.

In order to fulfill the requirements of Part 1 of Art. The Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation provides information about the persons participating in the case and their addresses:

Plaintiff - Individual entrepreneur Tuzov Yuri Vasilievich (183025, Murmansk region, Murmansk, Spolokhi St., 7, apt. 82, date of birth 07/08/1961, place of birth - Murmansk, OGRNIP 309519027500064, TIN 519100537846 , registration date 10/02/2009)

Defendant - JSC Insurance Group MSK (127006, Moscow, Dolgorukovskaya St., 40, OGRN 1021602843470, TIN 1655006421, registration date 04/19/1993)

3rd party - PILIGRIM.RU LLC (115054, Moscow, Pionerskaya St. B., 15, building 1, OGRN 1027739038513, TIN 7712090906, registration date 10/16/1996)

Taking into account the above, guided by Art. Art. , - Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation, court

DEFINED:

Send a writ to the Arbitration Court of the Murmansk Region to summon and question as witnesses:

1. Chernyavsky Andrey Sergeevich, born on July 19, 1976, a native of Murmansk, whose notification address is: 183039, Murmansk, st. New Plato, 18, apt. 52.

2. Sergei Vitalievich Sintsov, whose notification address is: 183014, Murmansk, Kolsky Avenue, 98, bldg. 4, apt. 60.

Questions to witness A.S. Chernyavsky

1. What education do you have? What is your experience working with ships?

2. What was your relationship with Piligrim.ru LLC?

3. What were your responsibilities?

4. Since when did you start sailing on the yacht “Katarina”?

6. When accepted, what condition was the Yacht “Katarina” in?

7. Have any repairs been carried out on the yacht “Katarina”? (If yes, which ones and in what order)?

8. Structurally, how many engines are provided on the yacht Katarina?

9. Name the brand, power, year of manufacture of the engine.

10. Was there a passport/form for the engine?

11. What kind of engine maintenance was performed?

12. When is the oil change?

13. What is the average fuel consumption while driving?

14. What kind of crew did you have on the yacht “Katarina”?

15. What characteristics did the yacht “Katarina” have?

16. Do you know for what purposes the yacht Katarina was used?

17. Did Piligrim.ru LLC have a license to transport passengers?

18. How often and from whom do you receive weather data when you go to sea?

20. What lineup did you have on that day? Number of crew members?

21. At the time of departure (02/20/2013), was the vessel in good condition?

22. How much fuel did you have to leave Teriberka?

23. At the time of release on February 20, 2013, was the engine “warranty”?

24. Have there been any engine failures during your work? If yes, which ones, when?

25. What was the engine hours as of 02/20/2013?

26. What other power source was on the yacht “Katarina”?

27. Who was the captain of the yacht “Katarina”?

28. Where did you come from and where did you go?

29. For what purposes did you go out (02/20/2013)?

30. What was the weather like at the time of release?

31. When and how did you receive the forecast for going to sea on February 20, 2013?

32. If the wind began to get stronger, why didn’t you go to a shelter to wait out the bad weather?

33. Was there a storm, at what time?

34. Were you aware of adverse weather conditions?

35. When did it dawn and when did it get dark on February 20, 2013?

36. Did you notify the border authority about your exit?

37. What distance from Teriberka to Murmansk did they have to travel?

38. How long did it take you to cover this distance?

39. What happened on February 20, 2013?

40. What actions did you take? Did Captain S.I. Kuritsyn help you?

41. What actions were taken by the captain?

42. How and after how long was the preliminary cause of the engine shutdown established?

43. How long did it take from stopping the engine to the first impact on the rocks?

44. What measures were taken to save the ship?

45. Do you know whether there were any ships in the vicinity of the alleged site of the shipwreck?

46. ​​How did you leave the yacht “Katarina”, was it already dark? How did you navigate?

47. Where did you land?

48. How long did it take to get from the crash site to the landing site?

49. Who came to save you and at what time?

50. Do you know the name of the ship that came out to rescue you?

51. Do you know about the future fate of the yacht “Katarina”?

52. What prevented you from saving the ship?

53. Are you familiar with the provisions of the Government of the Russian Federation No. 251 of March 24, 2009 “On measures to improve the system of control over sports courts in the Russian Federation”? Do you think that this ruling applies to the yacht “Katarina”, if not, why not?

54. The ship's ticket for the yacht "Katarina" indicates a limitation of the navigation area of ​​100 miles from the refuge. Does this mean that there are no restrictions on wind and waves for the yacht “Katarina”?

55. Were you present during the inspection of the yacht “Katarina” by the Sports Register on 03/29/2012? If yes, please describe the inspection procedure.

56. In the ship's ticket of the yacht "Katarina" in the section of inspections of the vessel by the inspector of the Sports Register there are stamps of the MMTP Yacht Club. Does the MMSP yacht club have the right to inspect yachts, on the basis of what document?

57. Do you have rules for the classification and technical supervision of sports and pleasure craft of the Sports Register?

58. Describe in detail the sailing rig of the yacht “Katarina”, indicating the area of ​​each sail.

59. Is there a storm sail set?

60. What registration number and where was it applied to the yacht “Katarina”?

61. List the navigation equipment of the yacht “Katarina” and its condition at the time of their departure from Teriberka.

62. Was there a life raft on the yacht “Katarina”? Was it installed with a hydrostat?

63. Was there a weather station on the yacht “Katarina”? What devices does it include?

64. Which government organization did you register for the yacht to go to sea on 02/20/2013?

65. How was the transition planning carried out? Has pre-laying been done? On paper maps or electronic ones?

66. What distance did you have to walk from Teriberka to Murmansk?

67. If the cards are electronic, then who is the manufacturer and what type of cards?

68. Are there any places of refuge in the area of ​​the island along the crossing route? Small Deer? Which ones exactly, how many are there, where are they located, what are their coordinates?

69. Why didn’t they install sailing rigs?

70. Was the entire transition planned under the engine?

71. What is the fuel supply on the ship?

72. What is the fuel consumption for the engine?

73. How and what forecast did you receive for leaving Teriberka? How often did you receive a forecast? Have you received a storm warning?

74. Describe how the weather changed after leaving Teriberka (Indicating the direction and speed of the wind). How did you measure the wind? Have you noticed a drop in pressure on the barometer?

75. What time did the engine stop? How long have you been trying to figure out the engine? It was already dark?

77. What sails must be raised on the yacht “Katarina” in order for the yacht to be steered?

79. Have you tried to anchor? Why didn't it work?

80. Did you see that the yacht “Katarina” sank? Could the yacht have remained afloat after you left on the inflatable boat?

81. How did the rescuers find you?

82. What measures were taken after your rescue to locate and salvage the yacht Katarina? Did the rescue ship "Murmanryba" approach the scene of the accident?

83. Are the island of Cape Oleniy and the mainland opposite the island inhabited?

84. To which government agency did you report the accident of the yacht “Katarina”?

85. Have you submitted an application to the Sports Register to exclude the yacht “Katarina” from the ship’s book (ship register)?

86. Do you have an extract from the ship book (ship register) of the Sports Register about the exclusion of the yacht “Katarina” due to its death?

87. What is the end point of your planned route: name, geographical location, number of miles from the port of Murmansk? Number of miles from the port of Teriberka?

88. Name the dates of your planned trip.

89. Describe in detail what the planned route was.

90. Did you receive, did you have a certificate of the minimum safe crew composition of the vessel from the Federal State Institution “Administration of the Sea Port of Murmansk”? Certificate of the port of Teriberka? What does this certificate indicate regarding the minimum crew size? Do you have the original now? Copy? Duplicate?

91. Have you received permission to go to sea from the captain of the port of Murmansk? What are the reasons (why yes or why no)? Permission from the port captain of Teriberka? What are the reasons (why yes or why no)? Is there an original?

92. Where was the yacht stored during the lay-up period?

93. How was the yacht transported to Teriberka? Describe in detail, indicating the dates of transportation of the yacht.

94. What are the provisions for winter navigation in the Murmansk region?

95. What navigation aids were on the yacht?

96. Have you been fishing?

97. Have you used networks? If yes, then how?

98. Exact time of going to sea? What time is the yacht launched?

Questions to witness S.V. Sintsov

1. What weather forecasts and from whom did you receive for the navigation area between Murmansk and Teriberka on 02/20-21/2013? Did you receive a storm warning for these dates?

3. When, how and from whom did you receive a message about the yacht Katarina in distress?

4. Do you know, during the period of receiving the message about the vessel in distress (yacht “Katarina”), that ships were passing in the vicinity of the Yacht “Katarina”?

5. According to the MRCC Reports, your ship and the Tituvenai ship were sent to rescue the yacht “Katarina”, why in the end did you come to rescue, and not Tituvenai? Did someone guide you? Who?

6. How long did it take you to get to the scene of the accident?

7. Did you keep in touch with the yacht during the passage?

8. When did you approach the scene of the accident?

9. What was the weather like in the area of ​​the accident? Was it already dark?

10. How and where did you find the crew of the yacht “Katarina”?

11. How did the rescue operation go?

12. How many crew members did you manage to save? How were the rescued crew members identified?

13. Did the captain of the yacht contact you with a request to inspect the area of ​​the accident in order to locate the yacht “Katarina”?

14. Was there a real opportunity to approach the accident site of the Yacht “Katarina” on your vessel?

15. On this day (02/20/2013) did you visually inspect the site of the wreck of the yacht “Katarina”?

16. Is your signature and seal on the extract from the ship's log book Murmanryba?

17. When and in what place did the crew members disembark after the shipwreck?

18. Have you examined the shores of the Mal Strait? Deer during daylight hours in order to detect the yacht "Katarina"?

19. Do you know whether a vessel similar in class and type to the yacht “Katarina” can sail freely in the Barents Sea without filling out documents and who supervises this?

20. Are you aware of similar cases at the site of the wreck of the Yacht “Katarina”, fishing nets, ropes, ropes, and remnants of trawler equipment being wound around the ship’s propellers? Has this happened in your practice?

Send a copy of the ruling to the Arbitration Court of the Murmansk Region.

The materials of the executed court order must be sent to the Moscow Arbitration Court (including copies of witnesses’ passports) or the reasons for the impossibility of fulfilling the order within a reasonable time must be reported.

Judge: D.I. Dzyuba

The cruise ship Kristina Katarina is currently operated by the Finnish shipping company Kristina Cruises.

The liner was laid down at the Stocnia Szczecinska im Adolfa Warskiego shipyard in Szczecin, Poland, under serial number B 492/03, commissioned by the Soviet Union as a Dmitri Shostakovich class sea passenger ferry, project B-492. The twin vessels are "Dmitry Shostakovich", "Georg Ots", "Mikhail Suslov", "Lev Tolstoy", "Mikhail Sholokhov" and "Konstantin Chernenko".

Launching took place on April 17, 1981. Commissioned in April 1982 under the name "Konstantin Simonov". Initially, the liner was handed over to the crew of the Far Eastern Shipping Company, home port of Vladivostok. On its first voyage, the ship departed from Riga to Cuba and returned to Odessa. Due to the lack of real loading in the Far East, on August 10, 1982, the ship was transferred to the Black Sea Shipping Company, home port of Odessa. The liner received the Black Sea crew led by captain S.I. Rodimy.

On January 9, 1987, the liner was transferred to the Baltic Shipping Company, home port of Leningrad. In 1987-1988, the ship was modernized at the West German shipyard Lloyd Werft in Bremerhaven; after modernization, it operated on the Leningrad-Helsinki-St. Petersburg line until 1996, lowering the Soviet flag and raising the Russian flag during this period.

On May 18, 1996, the liner was arrested in the port of Kiel for non-payment of debts and sold under the hammer to Pakartin Shipping Co. Ltd, which renamed it Francesca. The liner began to fly under the flag of the state of Cyprus, its home port is Limassol.

In September 2000, the liner was acquired by Abcus Shipping Ltd., which renamed the liner Iris. The liner changed its flag to Maltese, its home port is Valletta. After repairs were carried out in 2001, the Israeli company Mano Maritime delivered the liner to the Odessa - Haifa line, where it was operated until 2009.

On December 11, 2009, the liner was purchased by the cruise company Kristina Cruises to replace the liner “Kristina Regina”, built in 1960.

On February 24, 2010, registration was completed in the Finnish register, the Finnish flag was raised on the liner, and the port of Kotka was chosen as the home port.

The modernization of the ship was carried out by the Almaco concern in Kotka and Naantali, during which all 193 cabins, staircases, public areas, a conference room, a restaurant and much more were updated.

On August 31, 2010, the liner under the new name “Kristina Katarina” set off on its first cruise to the Mediterranean Sea.

In 2012, Kristina Katarina cruised the Mediterranean and Black Seas.

Cruise ship "Kristina Katarina", IMO: 7625811, flag Finland, home port of Kotka, was built in April 1982, serial number B 492/03. Shipbuilder: Stocnia Szczecinska im Adolfa Warskiego shipyard in Szczecin, Poland. Owner and operator: Kristina Cruises, Kotka, Finland.

Main characteristics: Displacement 12907 tons, deadweight 1762 tons. Length 137 meters, width 22 meters, draft 6 meters. Speed ​​15 knots. The liner has nine decks, six of which are passenger. Can accommodate 450 passengers, who will be accommodated in 193 cabins. The crew ranges from 90 to 100 people

On board the ship there are: two restaurants, a cafe, a bistro, a dance hall, a relaxation and reading club, an outdoor seawater swimming pool, a children's pool, a jacuzzi, a gym, a sauna, a beauty salon, a children's playroom, a shop, and an ironing room.

Kristina Cruises has canceled all of its cruises to the Canary Islands, which the cruise ship Kristina Katarina was scheduled to operate between November 28, 2013 and March 20, 2014 inclusive. The decision affects the plans of the shipping company's 2,500 customers. The cost of the cruise is 1200-2500 euros. The company promises to return money to customers.

On January 8, 2014, the liner was sold and transferred to new owners in the Canary Islands in Las Palmas. The liner was renamed Ocean Endeavor.

On 18-19 January 2014, the ship left Las Palmas for the port of Lerwick, Scotland, where it will be used as a houseboat for Shetland Gas Plant (SGP) workers for six months. The liner was chartered by Petrofac.

Share with friends or save for yourself:

Loading...